Full demolition for Winstanley and York estates as the chosen option

Author: Cyril Richert

Exhibitions at York Gardens Library on Saturday, 8 February 2014

Exhibitions at York Gardens Library on Saturday, 8 February 2014

Following the 2013 masterplan options consultation a ‘preferred option’ has now been presented to the local community: the full demolition / redevelopment of the estates is the chosen scheme, which received the greatest level of local support according to the Council’s team.You can view the preferred option exhibition boards on the council’s website as well as a summary booklet which is being sent to every home on the estates.

57% in favour of full demolition, but…

IMG_20140208_145015

According to the Winstanley-York regeneration team, 70% voted for option 2 or 3 (with 57% preferred option 3 meaning full redevelopment of both estates). Although the team promised us a break-down of the figures back last autumn, there was nothing as such in the preferred-option exhibition.

Never-mind, we worked out the figures working on the Appendix from Council paper 14-158 with the full consultation results.

As we wrote in a previous article the 57% approval does not reflect the great divide between Council tenants who have been promised a relocation in the new redeveloped estate, and the freeholders /leaseholder /private tenants who will be likely to have to leave the whole area of Clapham Junction definitely.

breakdown-results

The support for option 3 depends highly on who has been surveyed: York Road resident or Winstanley resident? Council tenant or private owner?

UPDATE: The council said in its press release that it has made a commitment that every council tenant and resident leaseholder who needs to move out of the old buildings would be offered a new home on the estate or close by.

Full redevelopment on Winstanley-York estates

Preferred Option = Option 3A

Preferred Option = Option 3A

The “preferred-option”, labelled as Option 3A and presented by the team, involves a greater level of change including replacing some existing housing blocks with modern ‘courtyard developments’ built around a traditional street layout. Some other housing blocks would be refurbished (although we could not see which and how many).

Option 3A also includes new development along the edge of York road which would provide a new library, health and leisure centre (only to replace the planned removal of the Battersea Sport Centre), a new community centre with homes above. According to the plan the overall size of York Garden will not decrease but will be surrounded by buildings.

More tall buildings near Falcon bridge

As the Council claim to put consultation at the heart of their masterplan, have we been consulted on the plan for the site closer to Falcon bridge which will be highly visible from both sides of the railway?

New-Towers_GrantRd

What they call “Bramlands” is the new developments along Grant Road and the new “station piazza” near Falcon Bridge, which is currently designed with a series of buildings the same height or taller than the current Falcon Towers.

Grant Road redevelopment (and area beside Falcon Bridge) as displayed in the brochure of the preferred option

Grant Road redevelopment (and area beside Falcon Bridge) as displayed in the brochure of the preferred option

As the Clapham Junction Action Group raised the issue in November 15th, 2013, it looks like again that all inputs from the community is being totally ignored (we were told: “don’t worry, this is just a masterplan“).

What next?

During 2014 the preferred option will be developed from an outline proposal into a more detailed masterplan.

The next major public consultation will take place in late 2014 when a more detailed design and delivery plan will be presented to the local community.

Eventually the new buildings could be delivered from 2018.

The expected time frame

The expected time frame

The scheme should be delivered in phases, with the first one being… the one that they haven’t properly consulted on: Grant Road-Falcon Bridge!

IMG_20140208_150613

If you want to let them know your views, please write to:
winstanleyyorkroad@wandsworth.go.uk
Tel: 020 8871 6802

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Full demolition for Winstanley and York estates as the chosen option

  1. We have similar problems with Wandsworth Council’s plans for the Danebury Avenue part of Roehampton. Perhaps WBC should rename themselves Wandsworth Property Development Corporation.
    They are spending £100,000s on consultants that could be spent on bringing the existing stock up to a decent standard. With services such as to the elderly with home help progressively cut over the past decade or more, where is this “new” money coming from?

  2. You are dreaming if you think council employees have enough experience, expertise and time to do what they pay good consultants to do. A few £100,000 is money well spent if it ends up with the right design and development. Would you rather the money was spent piecemeal and left to a few bob the builder contractors with no overall vision? That is exactly why we ended up with so much rubbish in the past. Some of the housing stock is not fit for purpose and needs to be demolished and rebuilt. Enough of the sticking plaster mentality.

  3. The so called consultation process was a con, We were presented with four options , options which WBC had chosen, All four contained the proposed major development along Grant Road. They present it as a “regeneration” to benefit existing Winstanley Estate residents when the reality is it’s a sell off to generate funds to keep council tax low and guarantee a future iincome stream.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s